About POP!

POP! is INQUIRER.net’s premier pop culture channel, delivering the latest news in the realm of pop culture, internet culture, social issues, and everything fun, weird, and wired. It is also home to POP! Sessions and POP! Hangout,
OG online entertainment programs in the
Philippines (streaming since 2015).

As the go-to destination for all things ‘in the now’, POP! features and curates the best relevant content for its young audience. It is also a strong advocate of fairness and truth in storytelling.

POP! is operated by INQUIRER.net’s award-winning native advertising team, BrandRoom.

Contact Us

Email us at [email protected]


MRP Building, Mola Corner Pasong Tirad Streets, Brgy La Paz, Makati City

Girl in a jacket

Timothee Chalamet as Wishbone? The humor of fan casting memes

Last May 25, the Nebraska Humane Society tweeted an announcement proclaiming Timothee Chalamet as the new actor for the film ‘Wishbone: Origins‘, a live-action adaptation being developed based on the 90’s TV series. Chalamet would be playing the lead role of the film, with the character being a dog.

However things don’t really seem to be adding up…

This was a joke, although some users were not aware of it. The Nebraska Humane Society made sure to clear things up through a follow up tweet. The made-up casting and movie were just playful wishful thinking, their own version of fan casting.

If things went their way, the Nebraska Humane Society shared that they would definitely cast Timothee Chalamet as Wishbone in Knives Out 2.

Fan casting has united many people through their predictions or suggestions for actors who would be the perfect fit for possible and upcoming movie roles. Mostly, fan castings focus on live-action adaptations of beloved cartoon feature films or shows. Stars are usually fan casted based on their uncanny similar physical appearance or their ability to bring the perfect energy to the role.

For example, fans have casted actors Bill Skarsgård and Laura Harrier as their dream leads if there was ever a live action remake of the Tim Burton film Corpse Bride.

fan casting
Bill Skarsgård and Laura Harrier fan cast in Corpse Bride

The beauty of fan casting is that it gives audiences opportunities to mix and match the stars they think are perfect for a particular role.

Fan casting also has a way of calling out Hollywood’s more questionable casting choices. Stars such as Emma Stone and Scarlett Johansson have been criticized for playing roles of Asian descent in their movies Aloha and Ghost in the Shell, respectively. 

But, just like most serious things that occur in the world, the internet found a way of making things funny.

Stone and Johansson have become constant subjects for jokes regarding fan casting. Sandra Oh even poked fun at the two during her opening monologue in the 2019 Golden Globes, which she co-hosted with Andy Samberg. Oh praised the film Crazy Rich Asians for being “the first studio film with an Asian American lead since Ghost in the Shell and Aloha” Along with the laughs of the crowd, Emma Stone’s voice was heard in the broadcast yelling, “I’m sorry”

The jokes definitely didn’t stop there.

Scarlett Johansson fan cast

The meme template also has a way of poking fun at itself, calling out other fan casts which continuously put the same trending actors into different roles.

Fan cast starter pack

Even the most humorous and sarcastic fan casts keep serious issues such as whitewashing in films in check as they keep the topic circulating. It’s great that we are finally seeing continuously increasing diversity in Hollywood film roles and people of color are finally getting the recognition they deserve… but all the hilarious fan casts are also kind of great too.

Scarlett Johansson fan cast

Scarlett Johansson whitewashing


Other POP! stories you might like:

Hot take: We shouldn’t be making fun of Tagalog dubbed TV shows

42% of Americans can’t name an Asian American: Here’s a list to fix that

Feminist misconceptions: Korean MC JaeJae, chocolate & being ‘anti-men’

Korean manner legs: Solving tall people problems one inch at a time

These Hollywood actors regret some of their past problematic roles

About Author

Senior Writer

Related Stories

Popping on POP!