Capcom faces lawsuit for unauthorized use of stock photos in Resident Evil & Devil May Cry
Author and artist Judy A. Juracek is currently suing Capcom over unauthorized use of her copyrighted materials in the Resident Evil and Devil May Cry series. The materials in question come from the 1996 publication of Juracek’s book entitled Surfaces, which is a large collection of real-life photos of surface textures that are “ready to be used in your designs, presentations, or comps, as backgrounds or for general visual information.” Surfaces also includes a CD-ROM containing digital copies of the photos.
In order to obtain higher quality copies of the said photos and for it to be used commercially, Juracek has to be contacted and paid for licensing, which Capcom reportedly never did.
In the court documents are comparisons of Juracek’s original photos to that of Capcom’s supposedly copy-pasted work. If looked at closely, the similarities become blatantly clear.
In the screenshot from court documents, we see G079 – a photo taken by Juracek of a unique glass shatter pattern that is almost impossible to reproduce physically. We see here that Capcom has superimposed G079 directly over the Resident Evil 4 logo.
In another screenshot from court documents, we see the original photo from Juracek labeled as W061. Beside it we see a door from Resident Evil 4 that clearly uses this original photo and uses it as a game texture.
The photo originally taken by Juracek was from a mansion in Rhode Island that apparently is not accessible to the public. Technically, it is impossible for Capcom to have snapped a picture similar to that of Juracek’s work.
What makes the case worse for Capcom is that when their private data was released due to a hacking in late 2020, hacked files with identical names to files in Surfaces’ CD-ROM were found.
Seen above is a photo file from the Surfaces’ CD-ROM known as ME009. Interestingly, a photo with the file name ME009 is seen in Capcom’s leaked files.
There is more evidence for Capcom’s unauthorized use of Judy A. Juracek’s photos in Resident Evil and in Devil May Cry, and people on social media were understandably frustrated.
I’ve seen the evidence for the alleged capcom stolen images lawsuit, it’s very compelling, and shocking that some of the taken texture files have the same exact file names. This is disappointing. Paying the original artist or simply asking for permission would’ve been so easy. 😩
— Suzi Hunter (@TheSphereHunter) June 6, 2021
Holy shit that lawsuit against Capcom honestly looks really bad for Capcom. I’m not sure how it will play out in court, but some of that proof looks pretty fucking silver bullet to me.
— EMP_Dark_Triad (@HBJohnXuandou) June 5, 2021
Others came to the defense of Capcom, but not exactly with the right mindset.
It’s multiple textures. The images line up exactly; something almost impossible to do by coincidence. And not every person on the planet is a gamer. They only found out about it last year due to the hack/leaks. Sounds like you just want to be snarky without knowing anything
— Fox Diamond (@FoxDiamondGamin) June 6, 2021
More idiots wanting money its done and over move on cause unless you have been redoing that copyright all these years you got no case
— MattsCreative (@MattsCreative1) June 6, 2021
Capcom already has a history of misconduct concerning copyrights, as a Dutch filmmaker is also suing the company for copying monster designs without permission for Resident Evil Village.
The beloved makers behind many of our favorite horror and thriller games seem to be in deep trouble, and rightfully so. It is only a matter of time before we find out if Capcom pays the damage fees demanded by Juracek, which amounts to a whopping $12 million.
POP! Creators/Zachary Israel Mirpuri
DISCLAIMER: All views and opinions expressed in this post are solely those of the contributor/s and do not represent those of InqPOP! and INQUIRER.net. The InqPOP! staff assumes no liability for any error in the content of this material. Got something you want to share to the world? Get a chance to publish your awesome creations and share it to the world through our InqPOP! Creator Community program. Send us your stories, videos, photos, fan fic, and even fan art at [email protected]
For more details, read the POP! Creators FAQ page.