The recent One Piece live-action adaptation has been gathering a lot of attention and praise from critics and the community alike. Even Eiichiro Oda, the author of the original manga, gave his blessing to the show, by giving Iñaki Godoy, the actor portraying Monkey D. Luffy, his iconic straw hat. Still, the show isn’t quite perfect.
The fight scenes are full of spectacle, enhanced by VFX and CGI, but at the root of it is that the actors actually perform most of their own stunts. This allows for fewer camera cuts and enables them to showcase more of the action, living up to the source material to a much greater extent. Mackenyu, the Japanese actor, actually has martial arts and sword fighting experience, so his casting as “Roronoa Zoro,” the swashbuckling pirate hunter, is very fitting.
During one of the fight scenes, Roronoa Zoro’s most precious sword is seen bending when he rolls to avoid an attack. Clearly, this was due to the actor wearing a foam replica during the stunt, but it sparked a lot of discussion online, especially on Twitter. Here are some of them:
trying to defend one piece live action but the bring up the clip of zoros sword bending when he rolls on the ground pic.twitter.com/c9CQSVpQZP
— luffy is stronger than goku (@minafromonce) September 6, 2023
I'm dead because my boyfriend caught the sword bending as well and proceeded to talk about it for the next ten minutes.
Ruined the one piece magic if you will. https://t.co/u2SjOZsJtK
— jae! 🐇 (@jantteoki) September 16, 2023
hi @netflix
loved the live rendition of ONE PIECE.
the way it holds us between comic & real, is a chef’s kiss.to the team 🥂
P.s.
a minor bug noticed in episode one/
zorro's sword sheath is seen bending like an air-filled balloon. I am not sure about the intention. pic.twitter.com/Qmj4pTPitp— & (@rahul__and) September 5, 2023
Man said game of thrones yeno with his big chest bruhhhh never put one piece next to game of thrones mannn jesus atleast the cup was hard to spot a mean you cant miss that sword bending unless your blind 🤣🤣🤣 but yeah keep game of thrones out of this conversation 🤣🤣🤣🤣 https://t.co/YLYWKWjRbT
— T (@TsinobiGaming) September 5, 2023
Meanwhile, a Taiwanese YouTuber known as Huber actually went through the trouble of manually fixing it, to make the sword not bent, as seen in their video.
They went through each frame and carefully painted a straight version of the swords, removed the old ones, and composited the straightened ones on top. A digital blacksmith. The comment section and other online discussions of this video all mention the YouTuber should be hired as a visual effect artist by the studio behind One Piece, so we may be seeing the start of a career.
It would seem fans love the adaptation, to the point where they want to make it just that little bit better, despite the amount of effort involved.
Other POP! stories that you might like:
Tragedy strikes the Jujutsu Kaisen fandom as one of the series’ beloved characters gets eliminated
‘Scott Pilgrim Takes Off’ releases a sneak peak of the series dropping this November
People are being reminded of ‘Forgetting Sarah Marshall’ because of its controversial cast
‘Confusing, but there’s an explanation’: Japanese man born in 1984 identifies as a 28-year-old
Content creator Sassa Gurl reminds fellow Filipino influencers about accountability
