Following their performance at a charity concert for the Nuestra Señora Del Pilar Shrine in Mamburao, Occidental Mindoro, Filipino singers Julie Anne San Jose and Jessica Vlliarubin, from GMA Network and Sparkle, have found themselves at the focus of a contentious online dispute.
While singing the energetic hits “Dancing Queen” by ABBA and “The Edge of Glory” by Lady Gaga, San Jose wore a glittery, sleeveless, and backless gown, causing several internet users and parishioners to denounce the performance as “insensitive,” arguing that the songs and clothes they chose are unsuitable for the occasion.
Although there isn’t a formal dress requirement for Catholic Masses or celebrations, modest clothing is often encouraged.
Church officials frequently forbade wearing shorts for males, sleeveless shirts, or miniskirts for women, especially when attending Mass. Some churches even employ usherettes who, before communion, provide people who might be dressed inappropriately with shawls or other covers.
In sacred areas, one is expected to treat others with reverence and respect, according to the General Instruction of the Roman Missal, which regulates Mass celebration.
Even though it doesn’t precisely control concerts, many people believe that playing secular music or doing activities in front of the altar that can be construed as irreverent crosses a line. Furthermore, it is emphasized in numerous Church publications and canon law that holy places, like the altar, should continue to be blessed.
The organization that oversees Julie Anne San Jose’s career, Sparkle GMA Artist Center, accepted accountability following the incident. The agency apologized for the situation and admitted to having played a part in the performance’s organization.
“We deeply regret any offense caused by the performance. It was not our intention to disrespect the Church or its congregation,” the agency expressed their sincere regret.
San Jose took to Facebook to publicly apologize for upsetting the crowd, emphasizing that her performance was intended to spread happiness and assist the church.
“I am offering my apologies. Even though my only intentions were to share the joy and support the church through the benefit concert, many have felt offended about my incident and my performance, which caused distress,” San Jose wrote.
She assured the public that the situation would not be repeated by acknowledging it as a “lesson learned.” San Jose also reaffirmed her faith and her dedication to her convictions.
“I am not perfect, but please know that I have strong beliefs, and my faith is unbreakable and cannot be shaken,” she reaffirmed her commitment to her faith.
The fragile balance that exists between popular culture and religious traditions is brought to light by this incident. The Catholic Church has a solid cultural foundation in the Philippines, and many parishioners are committed to upholding the sanctity of places of worship.
The outcry emphasizes how cautious planning is required when combining secular acts with sacred settings.
Other POP! stories you might like:
Commentary: How to spot grooming (don’t let people tell you otherwise)
Social media users decry viral ‘thanksgiving post’ from teacher deemed as ‘groomer’
Wake up, babe, new concert pet peeve just dropped: People up in arms over ‘lights on’ recording
