The Barbie loop: Why Gen Z keeps buying back its childhood

Barbie never really left the toy aisle, and neither did the kids who grew up with her. For Bielle Rasco, it started with a pink box.

“I remember this very vivid memory na, magmo-mall kayo ng friends mo, papasok kayo sa toy store. Tapos, you see this pink box,” she told POP! That pink box has followed a generation of Filipino kids well past childhood. 

Since Mattel introduced Barbie at the American International Toy Fair in New York in 1959, the doll has kept coming back as a toy, a DVD princess, a billion-dollar blockbuster, and a throwback accessory line. Each return carried the same quiet promise: remember how this felt?

Mattel Barbie Toys
via IMDb

Swept by nostalgia, the Gen Zs remembered, and many willingly opened their wallets. So why does the same doll keep coming back, and what happens when the people she was sold to grow up and notice?

Pink box, DVD shelf

For Filipino kids in the 2000s, Barbie lived on two shelves: one for dolls, one for discs.

Rasco’s first Barbie movie was ‘Barbie as Rapunzel,’ followed by ‘Barbie as the Princess and the Pauper.’ She remembered owning the matching Rapunzel doll, complete with magic scissors.

Bianca Santos grew up in a household that collected discs. “Imbes na libro, puro kami DVD case sa bookshelf,” she said. Her dad had his shelf, and she had hers, packed with shows like Barbie, Dora, and High Five.

She also played with her dolls in a way she described as “sobrang weird.” She owned only one Ken and kept her Barbies undressed, with all their clothes in one shared closet.

“I think that says a lot about kung sino ako ngayon,” she said.

Her parents fed the habit. “Kung pupunta ng Divisoria or Quiapo yung parents ko, bibili sila ng mga Barbie accessories for me, even though hindi sila kasya sa model ng Barbie doll ko,” she said. As long as she had a ton of accessories, she said, she was happy.

Today, she still kept a Spotify playlist of Barbie throwback songs. She said she would walk down the aisle to ‘If You Love Me for Me’ from ‘Barbie as the Princess and the Pauper.’

Growing up, spending up

Then Santos and Rasco grew up, and so did Barbie’s product line.

“Bigla siyang naglabas ng earphones case, ng phone case, things [curated] for adults, basically,” Rasco said. Her love for Barbie never ended. It simply found new shelves.

Santos noticed the same shift, but the new merchandise releases did not always land. She recalled a Barbie accessory line from Filipino jewelry brand Tala by Kyla that borrowed from the old movies, including a ring inspired by ‘Barbie: Princess Charm School’ and a heart pendant inspired by ‘Barbie and the Diamond Castle.’ She bought pieces from it.

“I think what I’m missing is like actual merchandise from the old movies,” Santos said.

Even so, she said the pull was real. “If something looked so Barbie, bibilhin ko talaga,” she added. 

Then her spending moved on. “Pero ngayon, parang hindi na ako yung target market,unfortunately,” she said. These days, she buys Pop Mart figures and small plushies instead of dolls. Her loyalty for collectible figures did not fade. It just changed brands.

Boxed in

The loop kept spinning through Greta Gerwig’s ‘Barbie’ in 2023, which earned more than $1.4 billion worldwide.

For Rasco, a philosophy graduate, the film landed differently. “Two worlds colliding, Barbie and philosophy,” she remembered thinking as she watched.

It did not reignite her love for the doll, she said. It fueled it. The scene that stuck with her was the one where Barbie gets trapped in her box.

“We’re all inside our own boxes,” she said. “Sino pa bang maglalabas sa boxes natin kung ‘di tayo?” 

The idea felt personal to her. Every Barbie came in a box portraying various roles, but once a child took her out, Barbie could be whoever she wanted. For a Gen Z graduate still figuring out what to do with her degree, that hit close to home.

Representation, with a receipt

Barbie’s newer dolls, which came in different body types, skin tones, and abilities, drew mixed feelings from both women.

Rasco felt a pang. “Where were all these dolls when I was growing up?” she said. But then, she changed her perspective. She said she should feel grateful instead of envious, because kids today could pick up a doll that looked like them. 

She also welcomed the shift. “It’s about time,” she said. Barbie’s reinvention showed girls that “kababae mong tao” did not have to be an insult, and that being pretty did not mean being dumb. “Pwede ka maging both,” she affirmed. 

Santos, who had just discussed the film in her gender and sexuality class, agreed that the step mattered. “Maganda ‘yung step na Barbie is taking, in terms of representation,” she said. 

“As Filipino women, we have to understand [that] at the end of the day, Mattel [the company behind Barbie] is a big corporation,” she said. Santos argued that Mattel expanded its range because “not everyone wants to buy a white skinny Barbie.” In her view, the drive behind this representation through these dolls was a strategy to get more buyers.

She also found Gerwig’s representation of feminism in the 2023 film lacking. Its message, she said, came across as “very white feminist” and skipped a real conversation about intersectionality. From a Filipina’s point of view, the idea of feminism is not the same as that of a skinny white woman. For one, a cisgender Filipina would not automatically understand what a trans woman went through in the Philippines.

“It’s still just a tactic,” she said. “It’s just another money-making scheme, I would say.”

Rasco also had a similar sentiment, “It’s a really good way of marketing Barbie.”

Why the loop never closed

Two fans looked at the same doll and drew two verdicts. Santos saw a corporation. Rasco saw a mirror. Even so, Santos still named Barbie her favorite media of all time. She even pointed to Sabrina Carpenter as the closest thing to a real-life Barbie. “If totoo si Barbie, parang siya yung nakikita ko,” she said. 

Rasco put it more simply. “If I could give Barbie half of my heart, I will,” she said.

That may be the real engine of the loop. Mattel did not invent these memories. It just kept the box on the shelf, and Gen Z came back for it, eyes open and wallet out.

 

 

Other POP! stories that you might like:

Somewhere between adulting, we lost our hobbies

I owe everything I know to fanfiction

Dear diary, meet my rant account

Read more...